Columbia
A High Schooler Pleads with Columbia
On Tuesday, the Empire State Development Corporation held its first public hearing on its outline for Columbia's 17-acre expansion into West Harlem.
One of the first speakers was the daughter, a senior in high school, of the Singh family, owner of a gas station at 129th Street. The gas station is one of two hold-out properties still at odds with Columbia; Nick Sprayregen's storage company is the other.
"If Columbia has to take [our property] away using eminent domain, I am sad to say, our future is looking very grim," the Singh daughter told the audience at City College. read more »
Sprayregen to Columbia: I Plead the Fifth, You Should Too
Nick Sprayregen, the landowner leading the final hold-out against Columbia's 17-acre West Harlem expansion, has an op-ed in today's Wall Street Journal. In it, Mr. Sprayregen (profiled by The Observer in July) attacks Columbia's threatened use of eminent domain to take his storage company's property.
In the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, the government is permitted to take private property only for "public use."
This clause was once limited to true public projects such as the construction of highways, fire houses and public libraries. But over the last 50 years it has been bastardized by the powerful (in collusion with compliant politicians and the acquiescence of the courts) into a weapon used routinely to forcibly take other people's property for nonpublic uses. What is occurring in West Harlem today is a prime example of this abuse.
SoCo... That Is All
The gentrification train keeps roaring its way up to Harlem and Morningside Heights, or should we say "SoCo."
Today Curbed posted two items that spell trouble or progress, depending on your point of view. W Hotel's parent company Starwood is building a branch of its new Aloft brand on Frederick Douglass Bpulevard and 124th Street. Aloft Harlem is slated to open in June 2010 next to an old carriage house that perhaps not coincidentally was long-rumored to be the site of a W hotel before it was recently converted to lofts.
And if the 125th Street rezoning, a luxury boutique hotel chain, and Columbia's expansion were not enough to seal upper Manhattan's fate, brokers have coined a pretentiously trendy name to attract young people to the nabe: "SoCo." read more »
125th Street Rezoning Rally: 1968 Tries Again
About 100 people turned up at a rally in Harlem on Saturday aimed at blocking the Bloomberg administration’s plan to rezone 125th Street to allow for denser residential and commercial development. But the rally quickly turned into an omnibus protest about everything from Columbia’s Harlem expansion to Robert Mugabe’s teetering government in Zimbabwe.
The Coalition to Save Harlem planned to create a human chain stretching across 125th Street from Second Avenue to Broadway. In the end, “Hands Across Harlem” only spanned about one block of the area to be rezoned, from Adam Clayton Powell Jr. Boulevard to Lenox Avenue, though we heard one organizer remark that it was a “pretty good turnout.” read more »
At Columbia, the Inadvertently Boldface Joanne Lipman Sticks to the Script
Last night, at Columbia's journalism school, Joanne Lipman said that three years ago she got a call from Si Newhouse. She met with him, had lunch, and loved the conversation so much she would have been perfectly satisfied with her life even if she'd been struck by a truck on her way out the door of his apartment building. read more »
Columbia Buys Site to House Displaced Tenants
Columbia University has closed on the purchase of a lot in West Harlem, with plans to build an apartment building that would house residents displaced by its 17-acre expansion into the neighborhood, property records show. read more »
Planning Commission Approves Columbia Expansion
The city Planning Commission voted early this afternoon to approve the expansion of Columbia University into West Harlem. The vote was 10 to 1, with one abstention. The plan next moves to the City Council for approval or rejection.
We'll have more on the Planning Commission vote very soon.
Community Board Committee Opposes Columbia Expansion Plan
The land-use committee of Community Board 9 voted on Wednesday evening to oppose Columbia University’s expansion into West Harlem. The committee wants a number of conditions met before it supports the Columbia plan, including the construction of low-income housing and certain environmental issues. The Times has more at its City Room blog.
A full Community Board vote’s scheduled for Monday. read more »
'Only the Sleaziest of Projects'—Harlem Protests Columbia's Expansion Timetable
TV Mogul Promises $400 M. to Columbia
"The reason that I'm doing this is because I believe in it," said the 92-year-old Mr. Kluge. Mr. Kluge has already donated over $100 million to the unversity to help with financial aid. This gift will continue this work, but with a focus on foreign students. "I look forward to Columbia having more global students. And what better city than the city of New York?"
Mr. Bollinger, whose expansion plans have been attacked recently, made it clear that this money is not in any way tied to his proposed Manhattanville expansion—although it could be used for that down the line.
"The gift will go towards the globalization and internationalization of the university" said Mr. Bollinger. "I'm not interested in buildings. I'm interested in minds."
Chipolte Opens Itself to Columbia Students
Chipotle, the wildly popular Denver-based burrito chain, will open a 2,800-square-foot outpost at 110th Street and Broadway in late July. The fast-food restaurant will be located on the northwest corner where the short-lived Casbah Rouge, a Moroccan restaurant, once sat. (It will also be across Broadway from a new luxury condo, diagonally across Broadway from a D'Agostino's grocery, and across 110th from a 24-hour Rite Aid that sells automatic ice-crushers. Ah, gentrified Morningside Heights; you look more and more like the Upper West Side with each passing year.)
Chipotle landed in the city in August 2003 with a store at 150 East 44th Street, and the line has been out the door ever since. The Columbia location will be the 16th outlet in the city, according to Katharine Smith, Chipotle's east coast PR person
There may be an extra treat in store for the Columbia student body. According to Ms. Smith, when Chipotle opens a new restaurant, it usually hosts either a fundraiser for a local non-profit or...wait for it...A FREE BURRITO DAY!
"We try and become a part of the community as soon as possible," Ms. Smith told The Real Estate on Friday afternoon.
It's safe to say that Chipotle would be welcomed to the neighborhood with open arms if they went with the latter option.
- Mark WellbornLipsky Attacks Lynch's Columbia Outreach, Lynch Responds
On his website, Lipsky writes that among other possible actions, critics of the plan "will be calling for an investigation of any conflicts of interest between elected officials on the LDC [local development corporation] and Bill Lynch, recently hired by Columbia to represent the university's interest."
I just got off the phone with Bill Lynch, who said the argument is pretty weak.
"Well I don't see how we have any conflict of interest," he said. "We've been hired by Columbia University to do outreach to the community and that's what we've done."
When asked about the elected officials in the area, Lynch said, "I know them all, but I don't have any official relationship with them."
Which, he said, leaves him a little puzzled as to what the problem is.
"I'm not a lawyer," Lynch said. "My lawyers tell me it's not a conflict of interest. It looks like they're grasping for straws. That's what it looks like to me."
-- Azi PaybarahThe Great Downshift Shtick
Like Overgrown Kids
"Columbia University should ban laptops in classrooms, or at least ban them until students learn how to use them correctly."
The full article is here.
-- Azi PaybarahParlor-Floor Pad in Berwind Sells
Columbia Salsas into Harlem
Based on how Columbia is treating me and is dealing with me, I don't feel apprehension.... I feel confident that I will be offered a space in the expansion zone.
All of which proves, if you can't stand the heat, duck under a plastic palm tree.
- Matthew SchuermanMr. Bollinger’s Battle
I Apologize Re Chomsky
Donald Trump Responds
Letters
Letters
The Round-Up: Thursday
- Fed leaves interest rates unchanged. [NY Times]
- Vornado-led group plans to raise Equity Office bid. [NY Times]
- 5,000-seat amphiteater for Coney Island? [NY Post]
- Find bargain surprises in Manhattan housing. [NY Post]
- Stipe buys Affleck's (Casey's, not Ben's) Tribeca penthouse. [NY Post]
- Feds slap two WTC site contractors with violations. [Daily News]
- Fulton Transit hub to have 24,000 commercial feet. [Daily News]
- Blight study may help Columbia's Harlem expansion. [NY Sun]
- A look at Lower Manhattan's Charles Maikish. [NY Sun]
- More on Lower Manhattan's revitalization. [NY Sun]
- Assessment letters upset city homeowners. [NY Sun]
Did we miss any New York City real estate news this morning? Please send along tips and links.
In This Week's Observer...
Actually, Obama Did Go to a 'Madrasah'
I beg to differ. Two weeks ago I attended a lecture on development in the Arab world at the 92d Street Y. The lecturer was Saifedean Ammous, a Palestinian graduate student in international studies at Columbia. A woman in the audience asked Ammous about all those terrible madrasah's that Arabs send their children to. Ammous answered that "madrasah" simply means school in Arabic, and he attended a Quaker madrasah in Ramallah.
I asked him about the point today; and Ammous emailed me:
The term Madrasah simply means school, and is used exactly as in English, so you could use it to refer to a Jewish, Christian or Islamic Madrasah, as well as a public, private, elementary or secondary Madrasah. In the English language, and due to the amount of coverage that some of these schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan have been getting over the last few years, the term Madrasah has been associated with religious schools that supposedly indoctrinate and train terrorists.Obama clearly went to a Madrasah in Indonesia, in that he clearly went to a school... Even if he did go to a religious school, that almost certainly doesn't mean that it was a place where they learned Koran and not Chemistry. In all likelihood it was an Islamic school inasmuch as Catholic schools in America are Catholic: a regular school teaching all the regular subjects, but putting a little extra emphasis on religion and the morality of its students.
I highly doubt that he had gone to what are known as "radical madrasas", I don't even know if they are common in Indonesia, and can imagine that his family, who seem largely secular, would've wanted to make sure their kid studies math and science.
Why Jews Are Not Leading an Antiwar Movement This Time Round
Historically, [Jews] have funded the Left... They were the major funders of the Civil Rights Movement. They were the funders of the anti-war movement during the Viet Nam War. If people were arrested, and they needed bail, progressive Jews provided the bail, and the lawyers were mostly Jewish... Going back into the thirties, you have Jews active in the unions, active in every radical movement. That's the tradition I grew up in. It no longer exists. As a matter of fact, it's been erased from Jewish history. Young Jews growing up in America today have no idea of the Jewish radical past in this country.
Blankfort points to the same problem I have pointed to, the Israel lobby, which saw crushing Iraq as in Israel's interest. But I'd like to throw in another factor: class. Since Vietnam, Jews have risen dramatically in American society. My people are now implicated in the power structure in ways we never imagined in the '60s. Back then Jews who joined the antiwar movement thought of themselves as outsiders in American life. Most of the white Columbia U. radicals, for instance Mark Rudd, the late Ted Gold, the imprisoned David Gilbert, Bob Feldmanwere Jewish kids from middle class backgrounds who felt alienated from a warmaking establishment.
Rudd, born Rudnitsky (his dad changed the name to advance in the military), writes in an essay on the Jewishness of the radicals:What outraged me and my comrades so much about Columbia, along with its hypocrisy, was the air of genteel civility. Or should I say gentile? Despite the presence of so many Jews in the faculty and among the students.. the place was dripping with goyishness... We were peasant children right out of the shtetls of New Jersey and Queens screaming, "You want to know the truth about Columbia University, they're a bunch of liberal imperialists! " Morally and emotionally we could not fit into the civilized world of the racist, defense-oriented modern university. Such was our ordeal of civility.
Today's Jewish world is not the shtetl. We have assimilated, we are the American success story. Morally and emotionally, Jewish kids tend to identify with blue-state powers-that-be. There are exceptions, but they are exceptions that prove the rule: as a body we have little class interest in challenging the assumptions of the (corrupt!) ruling class that got us into this disastrous war.
Which Way Should 125th Street Go?
"We're not about to turn 125th Street into 42nd Street or Wall Street," one participant in a public hearing on Wednesday night said.
Ahem. Isn't it sort of that way already?
The Columbia Spectator reports some resistance to the city's plan to make 125th Street more commercial and to create an "arts and entertainment sub-district." - Matthew SchuermanI Witness the Israel Lobby in Action
After Shaul's speech, representing "my comrades and not just myself," he was bombarded by hostile questions from Israel supporters in the audience. Shaul handled them with strength and ease. (Q. "Do you know of a counterpart organization where Palestinians question their moral decisions?" A. "I really don't careI am an Israeli who has to raise his children in Israel...")
Just as gripping to me was the discussion that took place after the event between Rachel Glaser, the campus coordinator of the rightwing Zionist Organization of America, and the students who had organized the event.
"What did this accomplish? What did it accomplish?" Glaser barked at the organizers.
"It achieved something important," one of the Jewish students said. "People perceive pro-Israel groups as monolithic. They think that we are not able to take responsibility for the bad things that happen."
Fine, Glaser said, but the students should have organized "a panel," in which Shaul was just one voice. "Have someone else," she said. (Just as the New York Theatre Workshop wanted to "contextualize" the Rachel Corrie play with pro-Israel voices.)
It was one thing to have Yehuda Shaul give a talk inside Israel, Glaser said. "Outside of Israel, you're playing with fire."
This chilling statement was a candid expression of the goals of the Israel lobby. A member of a Jewish organization was saying that it's OK to have a wide-open discussion of these issues in Israel, but it's dangerous to have such a discussion here. Why? Because America is the mainstay of support allowing Israel to continue its policies in the Occupied Territories. The Israel lobby fears that Americans, if left to their own devices, will abandon Israel, out of indifference, or antisemitism. So Americans must be influencedin this case by having the information they get about Israel/Palestine vetted, and by pressuring Jews on campus to toe the party line.
I bring this up because Glaser's group, the Zionist Organization of America, is now trying to have the Jewish group that sponsored Shaul's tour, the Union of Progressive Zionists, kicked out of a consortium of campus groups that promote Israel's image on campuses. Why? Because (per the Jewish Telegraphic Agency) "Jewish money should not be spent on programming that provides fodder for Israel's most virulent critics."
This is shameful news. Jews are better than this, America is better than this...
Former Rush & Molloy Intern to Edit Jossip
Since late September, when former Jossip editor Corynne Steindler left the media and celebrity gossip site for the New York Post's Page Six column, Jossip publisher David Hauslaib has been doing the daily blogging duties. Now, Newman will take over on Dec. 27.
Newman, a 24-year-old Columbia Universtiy graduate, said that she spoke to Hauslaib about the job after bumping into him at a Reuters-sponsored panel.
"She's really coming to the table with much more than you'd assume from the average intern at a gossip column," said Hauslaib. "She really understands the media business and the industry."
Newman has also been a research assistant to gossip-publishing saboteurix Kitty Kelley. This will be her first foray into blogging.
Newman said that blogging daily seemed "ambitious," but "not too overwhelming."
"I wish I was a little tech-savvier," she said, "but I can learn as I go on." --Michael CalderoneEvents for December 8, 2006
The newly appointed board of the Chinatown/Lower East Side Empire Zone will hold their first meeting.
The National Press Club in DC hosts "Hillary and the Presidency: Ethics, Policy and 'Bill.'"
Malcolm Smith announces upcoming legislative meeting on police procedures and community relations in response to the shooting of Sean Bell at Thomasina's in St. Albans, Queens.
Stephen Berger discusses the NYS Commission on Health Care's report on hospital closings at the Grand Hyatt.
Silda Wall Spitzer, Christine Quinn and Joel Klein speak at the Second Annual Hispanic Education Summit at Baruch College.
NYC DOT and Transportation Alternatives unveil new signs and pavement markings to promote safe cycling on Grand Street and East Broadway.
The New York State Urban Development Corporation meets at Empire State Development Corporation headquarters.
Carolyn Ho, mother of Lt. Ehren Watada, charged with refusing to deploy to Iraq, holds a press conference with peace activists at Church Center in UN Plaza.
Peter King keynotes New York Institute of Technology's conference on "Homeland Security: Safety, Immigration and Port Security" at the New York Institute of Technology in Old Westbury.
—Nicole BrydsonEditorials
Editorials
Editorials
Editorials
Columbia J-School: Exams Were Filed Too Fast for Profs, Students Say
Rangel Schools Ivy League
"I spoke about the draft at Columbia, Harvard and Brown. These kids don't even know there's a war in Iraq."
It doesn't sound like he's ready to let go of the issue any time soon, despite the near-unanimous lack of support he's received for a proposal to reinstate the draft. And Rangel, a decorated war veteran, will have the ability to make things increasingly uncomfortable for his newly empowered Democratic colleagues every day that goes by without a coherent alternative position on how to deal with Iraq.
-- Azi PaybarahScott Ritter on 'My Good Friend,' Israel
The great thing about Ritter's speech, before an ambivalent UWS audience, was its bluntness. In that sense, his rhetoric reflected an important lesson of the Iraq war (which Ritter had opposed). We all know, or we ought to by now, that concern for Israel's security played a role in America's disastrous war plans. Yet as Philip Zelikow of the 9/11 commission has said, It was an agenda that dare not speak its name. It was generally cloaked in language about bringing democracy to the Middle East that reporters who knew better parroted. This lack of straightforwardness has damaged the country. It has corrupted our journalism and our thinktanks, it has caused enormous bitterness and mistrustand justifiably. The feeling many Americans now have that they were lied to about the causes of one of the greatest mistakes in our history is going to echo through our lives for a long time...
I think the lack of straightforwardness reflected Jewish fears of antisemitism; that if a Christian nation was actually put to the test, and the alliance with Israel actually cost American lives, the American people would abandon Israel. And so the Middle East Forum likes to put up feel-good billboards saying, Israel's interest is also the American interest, and Israeli Ambassador Arens likes to say as he did in the Times yesterday that 9/11 put us and you in the same boat, got that? But attack Saddam in part because he has threatened Israel? Friends of Israel don't like to say that. They fear that the average American would do as Borat says they would doand throw the Jews down the well. Thus: the Israel lobby, which acts to shield the issue from open public debate.
Last night, Ritter said, We're not going to abandon "my good friend, the state of Israel," and I'm going to put that agenda right on the table. Very post-Iraq. I wanted to hug him. Such transparency is essential, when we try to sort out what we're talking about when we talk about Iran.
Of course the sequel to all this is that in identifying this interest baldly, we get to scrutinize it, everyone gets to weigh in, even Americans who are appalled by Israel's racialism and militarism. Last night Ritter said that Israel is out of control, "drunk with hubris, arrogance and power." Jimmy Carter says in a book published tomorrow that Israel's policies in the West Bank are apartheid. And John Mearsheimer says that this small country's policies are hurting our standing throughout the Arab world, and America should therefore insist that Israel change its policies, and we should use our full powers to make that happen; and if Israel fails to heed us, change the relationship. There's a word for what Ritter, Carter and Mearsheimer are doing: discussing.
Steven Holl Goes From Denver To Denmark

T is for Towers-in-a-Park?
Columbia prof and Chelsea architect Steven Holl, whose difficulties with Denver led him to drop out of a courthouse commission last month, just revealed a plan for an outer-district mixed-use center on the outskirts of Copenhagen, atop a regional rail network -- the point being that you can put high-density projects outside downtown as long as you have transit.
"It's tempting to imagine such lovely forms in the South Bronx, eastern Queens or even New Jersey, with links to airports and office-park suburbs," Alec Applebaum writes on StreetsBlog, "but it's hard to move this image beyond fantasy until the city gets serious about concentrating new development near transit hubs in under-built areas."
Read also the comments to Applebaum's post, which betray a suspicion of large lawns. For more pictures, check out the website for T-Husene. A reading knowledge of Danish is helpful. read more »
- Matthew SchuermanManhattanville Sues for Information
Grubs
Grubs
West End Café finally reopens ... as Havana Central

Hey Jack, how bout a mojito?
Albeit with a slightly altered moniker: Havana Central at the West End.
Dig it: Kerouac's favorite burger joint will begin serving Cuban cuisine next month, under the direction of new owner and Columbia U. grad Jeremy Merrin.
The historic Upper West Side bar--notoriously divided by the sign "Pigs over there, students over here," during the late '60s Columbia riots--was originally scheduled to reopen in September but got delayed by "construction complications," according to the Columbia Spectator.
The newly refurbished venue will commemorate its Beat-poet past with readings of Kerouac's On The Road and Allen Ginsberg's Howl next Friday night.
Full beboppin' event details after the jazzy jump. read more »
- Chris ShottEditorials
Students String for C.B.'s
This fall, the Beep recruited 13 graduate students in urban planning programs at Hunter, Columbia, Rutgers, New York University and the New School to advise community boards on specific projects. The students, working a minimum of 15 hours a week, will receive stipends of $2,500 a semester, which should give them a taste of the salaries of real-life urban planners.
-Matthew Schuerman














